Evil Under the Sun

Rating: **

Murder seems to follow Hercule Poirot wherever he goes. Vacationing at the Jolly Roger on Leathercombe Bay, the private detective instinctively feels the presence of evil – a sense of impending doom. Most of the guests center on Arlena Stuart, actress and seductress of men, as the cause of all the tension. Later, when she is found strangled, not many mourn her death.

This is not one of my favorite mysteries by the Queen of Crime. It lacked both drama, and a suitable plot twist. But one thing that I learned on re-reading this novel was the author’s methodology. She uses mainly two devices which either help or deter us in solving the crime. First are the various hints which are supposed to lead us to the murderer and are therefore significant. You learn to look out for any seemingly unnecessary stories about characters, or some prolonged conversation which is intended to show us some hidden mystery; but side-by-side to this, we have misleading hints that seem significant, but some part of the information is withheld so that we jump to the wrong conclusion! She, as always, remains superb at misleading, but we eventually realize that the clues were always there to find.

Agatha Christie’s characters are never successfully portrayed on television. This is because they are not fully developed, round characters. She has a tendency to stereotype and that is where I think the difficulty arises. Agatha Christie normally categorizes her characters into various types. But people are more than just types, we have to look at them from so many angles and even then we only manage to catch a glimpse. This book had a lot of her normal characterization, for example, we have the typical American couple with the talkative wife and the compliant husband (the same type of talkative American is portrayed in Murder on the Orient Express), we have the quiet, inexpressive Englishman who shows no emotion over the death of his wife, and finally, the nice, slightly pretty wife who has ‘brains’, a college education and hence no sex appeal!

Nevertheless, some of her characters are unique and fun to read about – I liked the depiction of Arlena Stuart as a man-crazy woman, who was actually to be pitied (read and find out about the reality of her personalty!), and of Rosamund Darnley, a successful business woman, who feels the lack of a husband and children.

Colonel Weston appears in this novel, an old friend of Poirot’s, he had previously appeared in the novel Peril at End House. Mrs. Gardiner also mentions one of Poirot’s previous cases Death on the Nile. I love the whole illusion of a separate world that Agatha creates with her reappearing characters, and references to old cases.


4 responses

  1. Co incidentally,I read this book just 3 days ago.Its a great review. After reading your review,and in hindsight,it does seem true that some of her characters are a little stereotyped (especially the talkative wife and the barely-responding-but-shrewd husband one,ive seen this one in sooo many of her books). In spite of that , I really did like this book and I did not see the end coming.I ,personally would give it 3.5 *s at least.[maybe its the fanboy in me,xD]P.S.- Its Rosamund Darnley

  2. Rosamund Stuart – I can't believe I did that! Thanks for telling me :). I agree that the ending was unexpected and it was a good book. The only thing is that she had somewhat copied this plot in the short story, Triangle at Rhodes, which made Evil Under the Sun less interesting as I had read the short story first :)It's so great to find a fellow Agatha Christie admirer!

  3. Yeah,I think you just hit the bull's eye with that one,the plot wasn't that alluring to you because you've read all her books and so,it seemed a bit same.[that happened to me with Taken at the Flood and Elephants can Remember,the deduction specially]I found this much more interesting because I've read just half of her books and the plot did not seem…old to me.Yeah,its great to find a fellow Christie admirer and hey! Im a Daphne Du Maurier fan too! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s